Switching Foods

November 18, 2010
By

By Jean Hofve, DVM

The spice of life is variety, or so they say. If that’s true for people, what about our dogs and cats?

I love the commercial where the lady puts down a bowl of new dog food, and the dog shoves it under the rug. The voice-over intones, “(Our food), every day.” It’s very clever advertising, intended to put all of your pet food dollars into just one manufacturer’s pocket.

But the concept is all wrong.

For many of us, our animal companions are our children. So let’s imagine for a moment that you actually have a child, let’s say a 2-year old boy, and let’s imagine taking him to the pediatrician for a check-up. The doctor bustles in, looks Junior over, then plunks a big can of Yummi-o’s down on the exam table.

“Good news,” he beams. “All the vitamins, minerals and a perfect balance of nutrients that Junior needs are right here in New Complete Yummi-o’s. Now all you have to do is make sure Junior gets three servings every day.” The doctor wags his finger at you as he continues in a serious voice, “Now, since this food is perfectly complete and balanced, you mustn’t feed Junior anything else -– no apples or oatmeal or broccoli or peanut butter and jelly sandwiches –- because those might cause a nutrient imbalance!”

Well, this sounds a little weird, but you trust the pediatrician – after all, it’s his name you see on all the gold-embossed university degrees on the exam-room wall – so you go ahead and put Junior on an all-Yummi-o’s diet.

Time passes, Junior grows, and by golly, it sure is cheap, easy and convenient to feed him. The next year you bring him in for his checkup, and the doctor is very pleased.

“He looks great,” says the doc. “I see you’ve been keeping him on Yummi-o’s. Terrific! Now, I have more good news for you! Yummi-o’s now comes in Life Stages! You’ll keep him on Yummi-o’s Growth until he starts kindergarten. Then he’ll go on Elementary Yummi-o’s until he hits middle school. Then you give him Adolescent Yummi-o’s until he’s 18, when he can be weaned onto the Adult formula. And it gets even better – you can eat it too! New Improved Yummi-o’s is complete and balanced for adults up to 65 years old.” Then he peers at you over his glasses. “Hmph,” he says, “Well, maybe Yummi-o’s Lite for you …!”

Ridiculous? Of course! What rational parent would feed a child only one food for years on end? Even if the food is, in fact, complete and balanced, most of us would consider it unnatural, even cruel to the child. Never give Junior a cracker or a carrot? No fresh food at all? Preposterous!

Then why does everyone think it’s okay to do it to a cat or dog? We would think a pediatrician who recommended a single food diet for a child was bonkers, yet when the veterinarian recommends a single food for our pampered puss, we obey without question. But feeding a dog or cat is not all that different from feeding a child.

It’s way past time to bring a little common sense to bear, and common sense dictates that an animal ought to get a variety of foods.

The veterinary literature is full of cases where nutritional deficiencies (or excesses) were discovered, and in virtually every one, the problem arose (or was discovered) because the animal was kept on one food for a long period of time.

Cats, being strict obligate carnivores, have most often been the unintended victims – taurine, copper, vitamin E and potassium deficiencies have turned up in cats fed certain foods (which were, by the way, “complete and balanced” according to the standards at the time) as their sole diet.

Dogs, whose omnivorous metabolism is more adaptable, haven’t had as many problems, though zinc and fatty acid deficiencies have occurred on certain poor quality foods. A zinc overdose in a commercial dog food sickened author Ann Martin’s dogs and started her on a quest through the maze of pet food manufacturing and regulation, detailed in her stunning book Food Pets Die For in 1997.

The Myth of Complete and Balanced

Wait a minute … aren’t we indeed talking about “complete and balanced” foods? How can a complete and balanced food have deficiencies or excesses of nutrients? Unfortunately, even for the best commercial pet foods, there are several places along the road to the retail store shelf where the food’s nutritional value can go astray.

  • First, the standards (published by AAFCO, the Association of American Feed Control Officials) by which the food is made aren’t perfect. Pet nutrition is an evolving science, and we don’t yet know all there is to know about it (if we ever will!). Veterinarians have seen many examples of how the particular nutritional needs of a species become known – mainly by stumbling on cases where they aren’t being met.
  • Second, the exact quantities of individual nutrients in a given ingredient may not be known, or may be inaccurately assessed. A batch of corn meal might be presumed to have a certain nutritional composition based on analyses of previous batches, but depending on the weather where it was grown, the soil conditions, and the type of fertilizer used, the exact amounts of each nutrient may vary.
  • Third is unknown ingredient quality. A vitamin-mineral premix purchased from an outside supplier and added to the food may guarantee minimum levels of each item, but if the quality control on that product was poor, as it may have been in the food Ann Martin’s dogs ate, which tested very high in zinc, the finished dog food will merely compound the error. The nutritional standards specify minimum levels, but for most nutrients, no maximum levels – so there is a significant probability that one or more nutrients may be excessive. Too much of some minerals may have adverse effects. For instance, crops grown in certain parts of the country will vary widely in selenium content – unless this is taken into account or tested for, a mineral mixture containing selenium may push the finished food to potentially toxic levels. One state feed control official surveyed a broad array of foods – dog, cat, adult, growth – for those nutrients listed in the AAFCO Nutrient Profiles. He discovered that some minerals could found in quantities 300 to 400 percent over the recommended minimum level. Manganese, one of the minerals most commonly over-supplemented, was recently shown to have a very narrow safety range in humans and can pose a health threat at levels far less than those found in many nutritional supplements. Similar studies have not yet been conducted in animals, but one might guess that dogs and cats could also develop problems from manganese at levels commonly present in pet food. Iodine excess in cat foods is suspected of contributing to the skyrocketing incidence of hyperthyroidism in older cats.
  • Fourth is processing. Veterinarian and pet food manufacturer Randy Wysong calls processing the “wild card” in the making of commercial pet food. The heat used in various stages of pet food manufacturing can alter many ingredients, some for the better and some for worse. Carbohydrates are made much more digestible by cooking, but proteins can be denatured, vitamins can be destroyed, and fats can be damaged by heat. In general, pet food manufacturers are aware of changes that occur in their products during processing, and compensate for heat-sensitive ingredients by adding supplements, such as extra vitamins, but alterations in proteins and fats are not generally accounted for.
  • Last but not least, the pet food manufacturer itself can make mistakes. As I looked through dozens of feed reports from around the country, it was obvious that virtually every manufacturer –- no matter how good, bad or indifferent its reputation –- at one time or another fails one or more tests for protein, calcium, magnesium or other nutrients. Over time, feeding the same food, from the same manufacturer, who continually buys from the same suppliers, can ultimately lead to health problems for your animal companion.

Consider all the different kinds of pet food on the market. When I started vet school, there were basically two kinds of pet food: adult, and puppy or kitten (growth/lactation); “light” foods were newly available and becoming ever more popular.

Looking at dog food today, we find all-life-stages food, puppy food, adult food, senior food, food for dogs with sensitive stomachs or sensitive skin, food for herding, sporting, toy, terrier, large, and giant breed dogs, vegetarian food, high performance food for working dogs, reduced calorie and light food for couch potato dogs, food for dogs with heart disease, kidney disease, liver disease, arthritis, digestive problems, cancer, diabetes, bladder stones, dandruff and dirty teeth. Lest our feline friends feel left out, there are designer diets for hairball hurlers, happy bladders, extra furry, tartared teeth, and a similar array of medical diets.

Cats, being less genetically diverse, have been spared some of this, but recently a spate of new foods for indoor, outdoor, and specific breeds of cats has arrived on the market. And, of course, most of the “prescription” diets available for dogs have a feline counterpart.

However, the standards for pet food nutrient levels remain the same today as they were when they were set in 1989 (for dogs) and 1991 (for cats). There is one chart for adult maintenance, and one chart for growth/lactation. (Food intended to treat disease must provide documentation to FDA that it actually works as advertised, but the research is done by the company making the food -– and the claim.) New standards for dog and cat nutrition were just recently published by the National Research Council, but it will likely take several years before they are reviewed and accepted by AAFCO and pet food manufacturers must abide by them.

Is There Really a Difference?

Is it just me, or is something wrong with this picture? How much different are these foods really from each other –- given that they all have to meet the same nutritional standards? For instance, if you look at the ingredient statements on the labels of regular versus large breed foods, they look pretty similar. In any case, the exact nutritional requirements of hundreds of breeds (and infinite combinations of breeds), every imaginable lifestyle, and each animal’s individual metabolism simply cannot be accurately known, at least not with current technology.

Moreover, even an individual animal’s needs may fluctuate, depending on the season, his activity level, normal variations in hormone levels and organ functions, infections, parasites like fleas, illness, and a host of other factors. A dog who spends a lot of time outdoors in Colorado may need a higher calorie/higher fat food in the winter to cope with the cold, but unless she is extremely active in warmer weather, such a food may put on the pounds if fed year-round. It does make a certain amount of sense to try to match the food to your animal’s particular needs, although whether you can really do this based solely on a manufacturer’s claims for its food is unlikely.

The Allergy Factor

Another pitfall of feeding a single food is the potential for your animal to develop an intolerance or allergy to one or more ingredients. A dietary intolerance is a reaction to something in the food, rather than the food itself.

The list of suspects is a long one and includes flavoring agents, coloring agents, emulsifiers, humectants, stabilizers, thickeners, texturizers, and dozens more. Different manufacturers use different additives, so changing foods periodically may avoid constant exposure to certain ingredients that could become a problem for your animal.

True food allergies are thought to be uncommon (though more common in cats than dogs), but many practitioners and veterinary nutritionists are coming to the conclusion that most, if not all, cases of inflammatory bowel disease are linked to food.

It usually takes months to years of exposure to a food to develop an allergy. Allergies are usually to proteins, which are found in animal products, of course, but also in to some extent in the cereal grains commonly used in pet food. Corn meal (also known as ground yellow corn) contains 9 percent protein, soybean flour contains 37 percent protein, and wheat contains 10 percent protein. Corn and wheat are very common allergens in pets.

Switching foods every three or four months, from chicken-and-corn, to lamb-and-rice or turkey-and-barley or duck-and-green peas or rattlesnake-and-quinoa may help prevent your animal companion from becoming food-allergic in the first place. (But remember to carefully check the ingredient list on the package –- a food legitimately labeled “rattlesnake-and-quinoa” could actually consist mainly of corn and chicken.)

A Matter of Taste

The last big reason to change foods periodically is to prevent finicky eating habits. Pet food makers are masters at making the food irresistibly tasty. Consequently, an animal fed a single food may become “addicted” to it. I once got a call from a woman whose cat would not only eat just one flavor of cat food, but it had to have been canned at a particular factory! Cans of the same flavor with a different code stamp were rejected by the cat. She was frantically searching from coast to coast to find more cans from that factory –- which had since closed down.

Some foods are produced on a “least cost” basis, and the ingredients may change significantly from batch to batch. “Fixed formula” foods always use the same ingredients. Depending on ingredient quality, such a food may be a better pick. But even fixed formula foods that use the same ingredients all the time may still periodically alter certain characteristics, such as size of the kibble, or flavoring components.

When you buy a new bag of the same food, it could be just different enough from the usual fare that your furry friend will turn up her nose at it. Or you might run out of her favorite food and not be able to get over to the pet supply store right away –- she’ll just have to eat something from the grocery store for a few days. If you board her, she may get fed whatever the kennel is using (errors can be made, even if you supply her own food).

It’s best to have your animal companion develop more “cosmopolitan” tastes, and be willing to eat whatever you give her. (For dogs in some situations, training to accept food only from you can and should be done, but that’s an issue beyond the scope of this book.)

Time is on Your Side

For animals who have had food available day and night (“free choice”), the first step is to go to a timed meal schedule, where you leave the food out for an hour in the morning and again for an hour in the evening, but put it away the rest of the time. Believe me, your cat will not starve to death in 12 hours. The eat-fast-eat schedule is more natural to carnivores, and gives their tummies time to rest between meals. Also with this schedule, you don’t have to worry about restricting the amounts you feed; the animal will eventually self-regulate very well on this schedule. The other big advantage of timed meals is that the pet will be hungry at meal time, and thus more willing to try new things. This is particularly critical when switching from dry to wet food with a finicky eater.

Easy Does It

When you decide to make the transition from one food to another, particularly dry food, be sure to plan ahead. You don’t want to run completely out of one food and just slap down a bowl of something new in front of Fluffy’s nose. He may not push it under the rug, but a sudden switch can cause tummy upset, which can lead to extremely unpleasant messes in the house!

If adding canned food or switching from dry to canned, this is also the time for an abundance of caution. The two forms of food are so vastly different, it will take some getting used to on the part of your pet’s tummy.

Once canned food is a regular staple, it doesn’t seem to be a problem to change flavors as often as every meal.

With dry food, for most dogs a four (or eight) day changeover works best. Young dogs usually adjust quickly; older dogs may need a little more time. For the first day (or two), feed 75 percent old food mixed with 25 percent new food. Then 50 percent each of old and new food, then 25 percent old food and 75 percent new food, and finally all new food. This gives the dog’s resident gut bacteria time to gear up to handle the new ingredients properly.

Many cat guardians have tried—and failed—to switch their cat to a better diet. A primary reason for that is the tendency of cats to turn their noses up at any new food.Cats often require more a more gradual (that is, sneaky) approach, with more intermediate stages over two to three weeks. Whether or not cats should even be fed dry food is a separate issue that is covered in another article.

Special Tricks for Cats

To a large extent, your cat’s food preferences were formed during kittenhood. In fact, many cats who have been fed only dry food their whole lives simply don’t recognize anything else as “food.” Getting a food-addicted cat just to change brands or flavors can be a major challenge. Cats dislike change in general, and messing with their dinner habits may not be welcome. But it is almost always possible to convert cats to a better diet.

For cats who have dry food available 24/7 (“free choice”), the first step is a timed meal schedule: leave the food out for 30-60 minutes in the morning and evening, but put it away the rest of the time. Your cat will not starve to death in 12 hours. The eat-fast-eat schedule is more natural to carnivores, and gives their tummies time to rest between meals. Don’t restrict the amount; put out plenty of food. The big advantage of timed meals is that the cat will be hungry at mealtime, and thus more willing to try new things.

When you make the transition from one food to another, plan ahead. Don’t run completely out of one food and just slap down a bowl of something new. Even if the cat will eat it, the sudden switch can cause tummy upset.

If adding raw food, or switching from dry to canned or raw, use caution and go slowly. These forms of food are so vastly different that it will take some serious getting used to on the part of your cat’s tummy. In the case of dry food, it may be easier to switch to canned food first, and then move to raw later if you desire. Just getting a dry-food addict to eat a good quality canned food is a worthwhile improvement! Holistic remedies like Spirit Essences can help get a cat to keep an open mind and be more willing to try new things.

If your cat refuses to touch dry food with canned or raw mixed in, offer only the new food for the first half of the meal period before offering their normal food. Many cats will be hungry enough to at least taste it. (Remember that when dry food gets wet, surface bacteria will rapidly grow; discard leftovers not eaten within the meal period.) If that doesn’t work, try these tricks:

  • Start with plain meat, without veggies or supplements.
  • Lightly brown the meat.
  • Sprinkle a handful of kibbles on top of the canned or raw food.
  • Crush the dry food into crumbs. Make tiny, bite-sized meatballs of the new food, and roll them in the crumbs

Make sure your cat is eating at least a little at each meal. If not, take a step backwards in terms of percentages, or offer your cat’s favorite food by itself. Cats (especially overweight cats) can get into big trouble if they miss even a few meals—they can quickly develop hepatic lipidosis (fatty liver disease). It is expensive to treat, and not all cats survive.

Tummy Issues?

Many (if not most) animals will have a change in stool, even diarrhea, with a change of diet. As long as the animal is still eating well and acting fine, diarrhea is nothing to worry about; in fact, it’s pretty normal, and will often persist for a week or two. (CAUTION: If your pet has additional symptoms, such as lethargy, poor appetite, or persistent vomiting, stop the new food and contact your veterinarian; there may be something else going on.)  There are several ways to prevent or resolve diarrhea due to diet change:

  • Make the switch very slowly; or decrease the amount of new food being fed and go back to a larger proportion of the old food.
  • Add a digestive enzyme supplement. You can get one made for pets, or use a human version from the health food store. Enzymes should be plant-based (not pancreas extracts) and include protease, lipase, amylase, and cellulase
  • Add probiotics to help balance the gut’s bacterial population. Probiotics are “friendly” bacteria such as Lactic acidophilus and Bifidobacterium bifidum.

Following Up

For the first two weeks after completing the changeover to the new food, closely monitor your animal’s appetite, stool quality and energy level, and be alert for unusual symptoms -– itchiness, runny eyes, diarrhea -– that could be telling you the food is not right for him. (Of course, if you see problems earlier, stop the changeover and go back to the old food. Try another brand, or a more gradual switch.) Eventually, you’ll be able to settle on three or four different foods you can use in rotation.

Remember, variety is critically important in your pet’s diet. As tempting as it is to stick with one brand or recipe or flavor that your cat prefers, be sure to mix it up with different meats and veggies. This ensures that your pet is getting a good balance of nutrients, vitamins, and minerals.

As always, your companion’s skin and coat quality, energy and activity level, and appetite are the best indicators of whether the food is compatible with his system and providing ample nutrition.

For Dr. Jean’s in-depth ebook on cat food and nutrition–as well as a list of her personally-recommended brands, please see What Cats Should Eat in our Bookstore or on Amazon.com.

Tags: ,

10 Responses to Switching Foods

  1. catlover on March 30, 2014 at 7:31 am

    I am currently feeding Science Diet dry and Friskies canned and obsessed about changing their food to grain free. I have tried in the past but they won’t eat it. Bought the best too. I am putting the old food on top of the new food but they still won’t eat it. I know you don’t recommend dry but am going to try switching from SD to Taste of the Wild. Even the feral cat I have on my porch doesn’t want the grain free. Please help.

    • Jean Hofve DVM on April 1, 2014 at 8:10 am

      There is no particular benefit to grain-free food if that food substitutes white potatoes, green peas, or similar high-sugar starchy vegetable–which is what Taste of the Wild does.

      Please re-read this article and follow ALL of the advice, including making a VERY GRADUAL change, which you obviously did not do from your description. Most cats will not accept a new food right off. It may take weeks or months to successfully get them off dry food. Even the worst canned food is way better than the best dry.

  2. Tannie on August 13, 2012 at 2:35 pm

    I have spent the last week trying to switch our cat from dry to wet food. I’m going crazy!I am really worried about her. Her behavior has changed she is not on her normal routine, and now won’t eat her dry food. She is not over weight but I know she needs to eat something, but will only eat a few pieces at a time. Is this normal or is she mad at me? I have tried raw food, chicken I cooked myself and all the high end grain free cat foods. she is not to happy with any of them. she did eat a few bites of the BFF. What should I do, wait it out?

    • jhofve77 on August 13, 2012 at 10:20 pm

      It can take weeks, months, or even years to make the switch. Please re-read the article!

      Cats don’t refuse to eat because they’re “mad.” Not eating means there’s a problem. If she is not eating enough, even for a few days, this can easily trigger very serious liver disease that require a vet’s immediate ttention.

      Please do not wait. Cats WILL starve themselves to death.

  3. Brook on January 30, 2012 at 1:07 pm

    I currently feed my two cats 4 different brands of wet food. Their proteins are currently venison, brushtail, chicken, turkey, and a variety of fish. They all are also grain-free. I feed them a different protein with every meal, so they do not get the same protein twice in a day, or even every 2 days. Is this different enough? Thanks for the site. I love the information you provide!

  4. Cathy on July 26, 2011 at 10:52 am

    My recently (4 mos. ago) rescued cat has itchy skin and intermittent loose smelly stool, which she has had ever since I adopted her. She eats Wysong Epigen 90 dry food now. She is very picky and refuses other foods I have offered for variety. It took a long time to switch her from the mediocre dry food she was eating at the shelter. Her vet wants her on a novel diet to test for food allergies but her current food is such high quality (cold processed, grain and starch free) that I have resisted. I should add that she has a beautiful coat and the vet has found no skin irritation or infection despite the scratching and licking. She is energetic and playful. What should a cat with these symptoms/ characteristics be eating, even if I could get her to switch again?

    • jhofve77 on July 26, 2011 at 12:51 pm

      Sorry, i can’t give specific advice for individual pets…but if you are interested in holistic treatment, including nutritional advice, you can find a practitioner in your area at http://www.holisticvetlist.com. For allergies I recommend Dr. Bert Brooks in Woodland, CA–he gets amazing results! Nevertheless I do not recommend dry food at all for many reasons; it certainly tends to cause more allergic and intolerance reactions, as well as more digestive upsets, than canned, raw, or homemade foods.

  5. Peggy Corcillo on December 1, 2010 at 7:35 pm

    What type of diet do you suggest for a cat with crystals in her urine?

Leave a Reply

Search This Site

Support Our Work

Please help support Dr. Jean's work on pet food regulation and quality standards.

Archives