Let’s Talk About Talk!

November 18, 2010
By

By Jackson Galaxy

Without fail, the most fascinating information about the cat world comes to us from our clients, subscribers and cat-loving friends, not merely from “book learning.” This time, we’d like to have a virtual roundtable with all of our readers about the topic of cat vocalization. We see many questions come to us around this topic. For instance, our friend and subscriber Lea W. from Lafayette, CO writes:

“I am wondering if people have done research on how cats communicate among themselves? What I have observed with my two darlings is that they often “talk” to one another verbally—it usually sounds like a question to me, and is usually a prelude to a wrestling match or a chase around the house…they never fight for real, so these conversations are not disagreements or arguments. They are merely “what’s up?” kind of conversations, I think…It would be fascinating to know more about how cats communicate with each other when they live together.”

From another perspective, I found this query from an anonymous poster on an Ethology listserve back in 1997:

“I heard recently that while domestic cats make the famous “meow” sound, this is not innate behavior in that they don’t (usually) use it to communicate with other cats, nor do wild or feral cats use this sound. Rather, this sound is used almost exclusively to communicate with humans.” The poster goes on to wonder if there had been any studies on cats mimicking human vocal patterns, since he had personally experienced “meows” that sounded unbelievably close to “hellos.”

When I set out to write this article, it was to explain the knowledge we have, in a scientific rather than experiential sense, about cat vocalizations. But, as time went on, there were so many more questions than answers that appeared, and the conclusion felt obvious—that was to open the floor for stories, experiences about how your cats verbally respond to each other, you and the other humans in your home, and the world around them.

Lets start with the facts. The accepted model continues to be the one put forward by M. Moelk in 1944. Cat vocalizations are divided into 3 categories with the following subcategories:

Murmur Pattern
1.    Grunt
2.    Purr
•    I – Greeting (request)
3.    Call
4.    Acknowledgment

Vowel Patterns
1.    Demand
a)    Whisper
b)    Begging Demand

2.    Bewilderment
a)    Worry
3.    Complaint
4.    Mating Cry (mild form)
5.    Anger Wail

Strained Intensity Patterns
1.    Growl
2.    Snarl
3.    Hiss
a)    Spit
4.    Mating Cry (intense form)
5.    Scream
6.    Refusal

Famed cat watcher Desmond Morris has suggested that the whole vocabulary of the vocal sounds of cats can be broken down into six simple messages: I am angry; I am frightened; I am in pain; I want attention; come with me; and I am inoffensive. However, one has to believe that a specific cat’s breed, age and life experience both with other cats and with humans, must shade this translation guide.

From my own experience, I know that cats have adapted many of their vocal patterns to fit the humans they live with. What the anonymous Ethology poster noted is something I see not only with my cats but with my clients—the plaintive “I’m hungry” mew for instance, sometimes seems like a spot-on mimic of their guardians asking, “are you hungry?”

Let’s face it—cats’ sense of hearing rates as one of the top in the whole animal kingdom. Cats can hear sounds as high-pitched as 65 KHz; a human’s hearing stops at just 20 KHz. Their vocal habits, then, should reflect this amazing range. My conclusion is that they use vocal patterns in our hearing range strictly for our benefit. If you’ve ever seen the “silent meow,” you can conclude one of two things: either they never got to explore vocalization properly during their crucial learning phase, or they are communicating—we just can’t hear it.

So, this opens up a bigger can of worms than it closes! Let’s hear from you. Collective experiences can help shape stronger theory. We’ll gather your data and report back.


For personal assistance with your cat’s behavior problems, call Jackson Galaxy to schedule a consultation at 310-316-6618, or find out more at JacksonGalaxy.com.

5 Responses to Let’s Talk About Talk!

  1. Robyn H on February 5, 2012 at 7:32 pm

    I have 2 cats, one a 11+yr old calico that used to be more vocal..she says “maw maw” quite clearly. Squeaks when she gets excited..and announces prey with “meh whr meh whr”. My other cat is about 6..she’s a rehabed feral cat..suffered unknown terrors and lost first litter due to Sonora desert trials.She would purr unaudibly for years.. After deworming,etc..she’s become very affectionate and very vocal. Lately she’s been “meow”ing when she wants something. And she purrs quite loud.She bonded with my yellow lab..grooming him,rubbing him..he passed 2 years ago. She greets me at the door, warns me of company, by looking at me with big eyes and

  2. Matthias on January 4, 2012 at 5:56 am

    Interesting article, it would be so cool to get some insight in the cat’s language. My cat meows when she wants a door to open (like when she wants to go outside), she sits next to the door and meows until someone comes to open it. when she sits in the kitchen and meows (same tone as for the door), she wants some wet food. Maybe there’s also an association with the place where she vocalises? Pretty weird is that when I prepare the food for her she starts rubbing my leg with her cheek while making a “prrrr” with an upper inflection, I think this is something like “owww yeaahhh, i like you giving me food, thank you!” ;). For attention she just meows very loud with much more volume and a longer tone than she would do in front of the door. In times of bad weather she easily gets bored and strolls around in the house making this terrible nagging sound (very loud and stretched tones like a very intense complaint), often right after that she completely freakes out in an overacted session of play (with her tail like this: ~). And the last vocalization I understand is the “hello” sound. In my opinion some of the vocalization is indeed created by association, a little bit like action/reaction pattern that they understand. I agree that some of the vocalization is the result of adapting to human interaction, it really feels like she wants to communicate with me by using her voice in some situations. For so far my experience with my talking cat, i hope more people post a comment on this matter so we can start comparing =).

  3. Lolo Mc on September 7, 2011 at 10:18 am

    When my cat is about to puke it really really sounds like he says “oh no! oh no! oh no!” The other cat gags but never pukes, it’s weird. :)

  4. Wayne on July 29, 2011 at 1:57 am

    I’m a little surprised to see no mention of one of the most distinctive and consistent vocalizations — the “Mawr! Maw-war!” kind of sound from the indoor-outdoor cat at the door, signifying, “Look what I caught!”

    • jhofve77 on July 29, 2011 at 7:48 am

      Yes, that’s certainly a good one…it’s also disturbingly similar to the “Look out, I just ate grass and I’m going to puke!” sound! ;-)

Leave a Reply

Search This Site

Support Our Work

Please help support Dr. Jean's work on pet food regulation and quality standards.

Archives